What Happens If You Sue Your Own Insurance Company?
Suing your own insurance company is a significant step, often a last resort after attempts at resolving a claim amicably have failed. It's a complex process with potential benefits and drawbacks. Understanding what to expect is crucial before embarking on this legal path.
This article will explore the process, potential outcomes, and factors to consider when contemplating such a lawsuit.
Why would someone sue their own insurance company?
Several reasons might lead someone to sue their insurer:
-
Unpaid or Underpaid Claims: This is the most common reason. Insurers may deny a claim entirely, offer a settlement far below the actual damages, or delay payment unreasonably. This is particularly frustrating when dealing with significant losses, like damage to a home or serious injury claims.
-
Bad Faith: Insurance companies have a legal duty to act in good faith when handling claims. Failing to investigate claims thoroughly, refusing to pay legitimate claims, or employing delaying tactics can all constitute bad faith. Proving bad faith often requires demonstrating a pattern of misconduct or intentional wrongdoing.
-
Breach of Contract: Your insurance policy is a contract. If the insurer violates the terms of the contract—for example, failing to provide coverage as promised—you may have grounds to sue for breach of contract.
-
Failure to Defend: In cases involving liability, like a car accident, the insurer is usually obligated to defend you against lawsuits. If they fail to provide adequate legal representation, you might sue them for this breach of duty.
What is the process of suing your own insurance company?
Suing your insurer typically involves the following steps:
-
Demand Letter: Before filing a lawsuit, it’s generally advisable to send a formal demand letter to your insurance company, outlining the specific issues and the relief you are seeking. This gives them a chance to rectify the situation without litigation.
-
Filing a Lawsuit: If the demand letter fails to resolve the matter, you will need to file a lawsuit in the appropriate court. This involves completing legal paperwork and paying court fees.
-
Discovery: This phase involves exchanging information with the insurance company. This can include providing documents, giving depositions (sworn testimony), and answering written questions.
-
Negotiation and Settlement: Even after a lawsuit is filed, many cases settle before going to trial. Your attorney will negotiate with the insurance company’s lawyers to try and reach a fair settlement.
-
Trial: If a settlement isn't reached, the case proceeds to trial. This involves presenting evidence and witnesses to a judge or jury.
-
Appeal: If you're unhappy with the trial's outcome, you may be able to appeal the decision to a higher court.
What are the potential outcomes of suing your own insurance company?
The outcome of suing your insurance company can vary widely depending on the specifics of your case. Possible outcomes include:
-
Winning your claim: The court may order the insurance company to pay your claim in full, plus additional damages for things like bad faith or breach of contract.
-
Partial recovery: You may receive some, but not all, of the compensation you sought.
-
Losing the lawsuit: In some cases, the court may rule in favor of the insurance company. This means you would not only fail to recover your claim but may also have to pay court costs and your attorney's fees.
What are the costs associated with suing your insurance company?
Legal fees are a major concern. Attorneys often work on a contingency basis, meaning they only get paid if you win the case, but they'll still take a significant percentage of your settlement. Even if you win, you might also be responsible for court costs, expert witness fees, and other expenses.
What should I consider before suing my own insurance company?
Before pursuing legal action, carefully weigh the pros and cons. Consider:
- The strength of your case: Do you have strong evidence to support your claim?
- The costs involved: Can you afford the potential legal fees and expenses?
- The potential benefits: Is the potential recovery worth the time, effort, and expense of litigation?
- Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): Explore options like mediation or arbitration before resorting to a lawsuit. These methods are often less expensive and time-consuming.
Suing your insurance company is a serious decision with significant ramifications. It's essential to consult with an experienced attorney specializing in insurance litigation to assess your options and determine the best course of action. They can help you understand your rights, evaluate the strength of your case, and guide you through the legal process. Remember, seeking legal advice is crucial before initiating any lawsuit.
